
The cranberries and hot dogs thing was too gross to not point out. Sorry? — Dan
Churn and Burn?
Somewhere in your refrigerator right now, there’s probably a stick or two of butter. Each one weighs a quarter of a pound, and unless you’re baking a lot of cookies, there’s simply no such need for you to have that much better. And that’s a good thing, because in small amounts like that, you don’t run the risk of a massive fire.
No, butter doesn’t usually turn into an inferno. But in 1991, there was an exception. And it wasn’t as good as those cookies.
In the 1980s, federal price supports had guaranteed dairy farmers a set price for their milk, and when farmers produced more than anyone wanted to buy, the government ended up owning the excess — as butter and cheese, mostly, stored in warehouses around the country until it could be given away, as a longtime dairy columnist explained in the Wisconsin State Farmer. One of those warehouses was Central Storage & Warehouse Co. in Madison, Wisconsin, which according to the Associated Press was holding 10 to 15 million pounds of government surplus butter, alongside cheese, cranberries, and several million pounds of Oscar Mayer hot dogs and sausages.
All that food was safe and sound — it’s not like it was going to start cooking itself. (Besides, cranberries and hot dogs in a butter and cheese sauce? Gross.) But on May 3, 1991, a forklift turned itself on — and that was bad, because the forklift was parked in an aisle, out of service and waiting for a warranty repair, with nobody at the controls. And as the warehouse’s owner, Ken Williams, later told the Wisconsin State Journal, its forks rose on their own until they could rise no further, and the motor kept running anyway, bursting the machine’s hydraulic lines. Flammable fluid sprayed onto hot machine parts and onto the shrink-wrapped hot dogs stacked nearby. By Williams’ account, the fire was through the roof in about three and a half minutes — too fast for the sprinklers to matter. Within ten minutes of the first fire trucks arriving, per the Madison Fire Department’s history of the blaze, 911 callers were reporting flames 300 feet high.
And then, things got worse.
A freezer full of butter is, in the end, a building full of fat, and when the walls came down, the fat came out. Firefighters described “rivers of hot flowing liquid,” according to the trade journal Fire Engineering, and the more water they poured on — 21 million gallons in the first two days — the more of it flowed. Then the cold water and the cool spring air turned the liquid back into a solid, leaving crews wading through grease that was waist-deep in places. Steven Davis, a second-year firefighter who would later become the city’s fire chief, stepped off a loading dock onto what looked like solid ground and sank to his chest. “It literally was a river of butter,” he told local culture site Tone Madison thirty years later. The butter formed a moat around the fire trucks: the ladder trucks couldn’t get out and the fuel trucks couldn’t get in, so mechanics hiked through it carrying diesel in five-gallon buckets.
And the butter wasn’t done. Downhill from the warehouse sat Starkweather Creek, which empties into Lake Monona, and millions of pounds of melted dairy would have used up the oxygen in both, a state biologist told the AP — undoing a $1 million cleanup the watershed had just received. So while one set of crews fought the fire, another fought the butter, throwing up dams and steering the flow into two stormwater ponds, then pumping some 14 million gallons of butter-and-water into the city’s sewers over three days. When it rained on the third day and the ponds threatened to spill over the last dam, they built two more before noon. It worked: “Very, very little got into the creek,” a state official told the AP.
The fire was declared under control after two days and officially out after eight. Nobody was killed, though about 3,000 neighbors spent a night evacuated, and the loss came to nearly $80 million, almost all of it food. The fire department threw away most of the gear it had used. The smell — popcorn, baked ham, and burned cranberries, by Davis’s description — hung around the nearest fire station for years, and one lieutenant told Madison’s NBC15 two decades later that he still couldn’t eat hot dogs. The warehouse sued the forklift’s manufacturer and won. So did the federal government, which wanted to be paid back for its butter.
Central Storage rebuilt, and its new freezer opened that September, stocked this time with 16 million pounds of cranberries. As for the spot where the river of butter first broke loose, Tone Madison reports that there’s a restaurant a few yards away now: a Culver’s, a chain best known for a sandwich called the ButterBurger. They probably don’t add cranberries.
13 Retirement Investment Blunders to Avoid


Can you spot investment mistakes before they cost you? Our guide, 13 Retirement Investment Blunders to Avoid, reveals common errors that can quietly erode your savings, so you can make more informed decisions for your future. You’ll learn ways to manage excessive fees, plan for inflation, invest beyond the US and stay disciplined through market swings. If you’ve saved over $1 million, these strategies can help position your portfolio to support a long, comfortable retirement. When you’re ready to talk through your situation, schedule a call with one of our dedicated professionals. We can discuss these strategies and opportunities to help improve your plan.
More About Butter
Today’s Bonus fact: No one can eat 10 to 15 million pounds of butter themselves, but what if you tried? Bad, bad stuff can happen — well beyond the bad stuff you’d expect. In 2025, doctors in Tampa reported the case of a man in his 40s who spent eight months on an all-meat-and-dairy diet, eating six to nine pounds of butter, cheese, and hamburgers a day. His cholesterol rose about fivefold, and painless yellow deposits of it began appearing on his eyelids, then his palms, the soles of his feet, and his elbows. The medical journal that first reported on his story doesn’t go into what happened to him after, but it probably wasn’t something you should try to discover on your own.
From the Archives: The Great Norwegian Butter Crisis of 2011: When butter ran dry.
Support Now I Know!
Now I Know is supported by readers like you. Yes, you! Many of my readers donate a few dollars a month to help Now I Know grow and thrive. And in exchange, they get an ad-free version!
Interested in supporting Now I Know? Click here!
And thanks! — Dan
